
 
Revised  HR 2-11 
 
 
 
 
New Employee Performance Evaluation  
INFORMATION AND INSTRUCTIONS 
 
General Information and Timeframe for Completion 
New employees or employees who have moved into a new job will have performance evaluated early in the new assignment.  The New 
Employee Performance Evaluation is an opportunity for the supervisor to review the employee performance prior to the end of the new hire 
(probationary) period of six months and to confirm a recommendation for continued employment or extend a probationary period.  The New 
Employee Performance Evaluation is an opportunity to reiterate goals and expectations with a new team member.  Training and development 
needs are discussed and a plan is established as applicable.  At this time, the new employee should determine if he/she is committed to continued 
employment at NSU. 
 
New employees may have performance evaluated anytime during the new hire period as needed or appropriate. An employee who is consistently 
falling below expectations on duties or who falls below expectations on critical duties should not have continued employment confirmed.  
 
New employee should be evaluated no later than one month prior to the end (5 months) of their new hire (probationary) period. Refer to the 
Human Resources Procedure Manual for all Employees for detailed information. 
 
Steps to Completion of Performance Evaluation  
1.  Supervisor should review job description.  
 
2.  Remember that the primary goal with performance evaluation is for productive two-way communication between the employee and the 
supervisor. 
 
3. Supervisor should schedule an evaluation review discussion with the employee, give employee the Areas for Discussion at Performance 
Review (page 3) of the evaluation form in advance and receive the completed form (page 3) from the employee prior to the meeting.  
 
4. Supervisor should complete the Ninety-Day Performance Evaluation form (pages 1 and 2) according to the instructions below.  
 
5. Employee completes the discussion form (page 3) and forwards to supervisor. 
 
6. Supervisor gets ready for discussion by having 2 copies of the completed Ninety-Day Performance Appraisal form (pages 1 and 2.)  
 
7. Supervisor and employee meet and discuss the evaluation.  
Begin with discussion of job description.  
Ask about concerns or needs from the new employee. 
Discuss successes.  
Make plans for areas in need of improvement.  
Set goals with at least one goal related to NSU Mission, Vision, Values or the Service Excellence Values. 
 
8. Discuss the Service Excellence Values and the NSU Mission, Vision and Values. Include your expectation within your department and how 
you evaluate this. Now is a good time to identify strengths and opportunities related to the Service Excellence Values.  
 
9. The entire completed and signed evaluation form and any accompanying information are submitted to the Office of Human Resources for 
inclusion in personnel file.  
 
Performance Evaluation Form Example 
General Employment Performance  
The supervisor may have assigned specific requirements in these categories or may relate them to overall employment issues. This rating 
indicates how well the employee has used skills to do their job. Feel free to add specific requirements to each item. Attach additional pages as 
necessary. Any rating above or below “meets expectations” should include a comment.  
Work Skills—prioritizing assignments, time management, initiative, creativity, etc. 
Specific Items:       meets deadlines 80% of time. 
Specific Items:       no initiative to complete new filing system. 
Specific Items:      designed new webpage for dept.